If you’ve been stuck on how to go about scar treatment, here’s a comprehensive Scaraway vs Mederma comparison to help you make up your mind. The two medications are good recommendations for scar treatment but what are main the differences between them?
Scaraway is a silicone gel-based scar treatment product while Mederma is an onion extract gel-based scar treatment product. And if you are wondering which product is best for stretch marks, old and new scars, hang on and let’s find out.
EDITOR'S CHOICE  |
ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel
|
Check Price |
RUNNER UP  |
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel
|
Check Price |
Scaraway or Mederma: Differences & Similarities
Scaraway is a 100% silicone gel-based scar treatment medication with a vast background of clinical research to ensure its effectiveness in dealing with hypertrophic scars and keloids.
Conversely, Mederma is an onion extract gel used for managing scar treatment and is equally effective. Albeit a few mixed clinical evidence in its use, Mederma is a popular scar treatment that’s been around for more than 15 years.
Another difference between the two is that Scaraway’s ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel is applied twice a day while Mederma’s Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is applied once a day.
The similarities between these two products are that both are gels and work for all types of scars.
Their major differences are noted in terms of ingredients, effectiveness, purpose, manufacturer, and prices and are highlighted below. But first, let’s see which one is more effective for stretch marks, old and new scars.
Scaraway vs Mederma: Which One is Better for Stretch Marks?
However, in this case, Mederma’s Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy wins for the successful management of stretch marks.
In fact, the manufacturers are so sure about this product that they even offered a 100% money-back guarantee if the desired outcome is not realized after appropriate use.
Scaraway and Mederma: Which One is Better for scars?
It’s unique silicone gel-based formulation using the Polysiloxanes (Silicone Gel) as the main ingredient is highly effective.
It works perfectly in reducing scar height and weight, preventing new scar formation, reducing dark spots and skin discoloration as well as limiting hyperpigmentation.
Mederma’s Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy also works just fine for scars but it’s inferior to Scaraway in dealing with scars. However, for mild scars, it’s a good option.
Which One is Better for new scars?
Even for new scars, ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel still wins. Silicon gel-based products are more superior to onion extract-based products in dealing with all kinds of scars.
Which One is Better for old scars?
ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel. The Polysiloxanes (Silicone Gel) in Scaraway works magic in the treatment of old scars as compared to Mederma’s Mederma Advanced Scar Gel.
Ingredients
Scaraway is a pure silicone gel-based scar treatment product with the active ingredient being Polysiloxanes (Silicone Gel).
Mederma, on the contrary, is an onion extract with Cepalin® as its core ingredient.
Purpose
Both products are effective means of dealing with all types of scars, including hypertrophic scars, keloids, surgical scars, burns and injuries, and scars on the face, hands and other notable areas.
Both products will help you reduce skin discoloration, dark spots, dry skin, and stretch marks. Some variations of each brand may fit more specific uses, for example, Mederma has Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy for management of stretch marks.
Effectiveness
As far as effectiveness goes, Scaraway again comes out more superior and effective for the management of all types of scars and has been used for years. This is generally the trend with all silicone gel-based scar treatment products.
Mederma also works fine for scars and keloids but most people prefer using it for mild or new scars. It’s also fairly affordable given its packaging as compared to Scaraway.
Both products work perfectly in reducing the size and height of scars, prevents new scar formation, limits skin discoloration and hyperpigmentation, and reduces dark spots and stretch marks.
Furthermore, both products are easy to apply, lightweight, clears quickly, and possess no strong scent.
Price
Mederma’s Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is slightly more expensive than Scaraway’s ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel.
However, Mederma Advanced Scar Gel’s packaging is actually 2.5 times larger than ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel’s packaging.
For some, that could be a thing to consider before choosing between the two in terms of price.
Manufacturer
Scaraway’s ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel is manufactured by Perrigo, an Irish-based pharmaceutical giant specializing in self-care medications. It’s purely silicone gel-based and works for all types of scars.
Mederma’s Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy is manufactured by Germany’s pharmaceutical giant, Merz. Both products have had huge success over the years and are recommended by both surgeons and dermatologists.
Scaraway Review
It’s a 100% Silicone gel-based product for the management of all hypertrophic scars and keloids.
With just two applications a day, Scaraway will help you flatten your scars, reduce dark spots and skin discoloration and prevent new scar formation.
It is odorless, lightweight, has a silky smooth texture and clears very quickly after application.
Pros
- Dries fast
- Very easy to apply
- Best for all hypertrophic scars and keloids treatment
- Is silicone gel-based
- Is thin, odorless and clear
Cons
- The roller tip is likely to get clogged after repeated use
- Requires patience for utmost results to be enjoyed
Mederma Review
It’s best known to handle all types of hypertrophic scars and keloids but most people prefer it for mild and new scars.
Like Scaraway, it will help you prevent new scar formulation, flatten old and existing scars, reduce dark spots and skin discoloration.
Mederma’s Mederma Advanced Scar Gel has a mild scent, dries quickly and is easy to apply. It’s fairly affordable and is only applied once a day.
Pros
- Contains Cepalin, an onion extract
- Has a mild scent and light in texture
- Known to dry quickly and is easy to apply
- Recommended for all known scars (old and new) and keloids
- Fairly cheaper compared to Dermatix
Cons
- Has limited research to backs its effectiveness but has been around for more than 15 years
- Has also yielded varying clinical results
Conclusion
Scaraway Vs Mederma: And the winner is…
This is not a hard one to conclude based on the fact that we are comparing a silicone gel-based product to an onion extract-based product. Therefore, ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel takes the top spot.
Mederma’s Mederma Advanced Scar Gel promises good results but has also produced mixed clinical results, particularly in scar treatment. However, for stretch marks, Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy is the better option.