Have you been struggling with scars or stretch marks? We’ve finally managed to solve the BioCorneum vs Mederma debate so you don’t have to struggle in choosing between them.
These two medications are recommended for scars but they pack in them different qualities and it’s only good if we find out what they constitute.
We will also show you which one between BioCorneum and Mederma is best for the treatment of stretch marks as well as for old and new scars. Ready? Let’s go!
EDITOR'S CHOICE  |
BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment
|
Check Price |
RUNNER UP  |
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream
|
Check Price |
BioCorneum vs Mederma: Differences & Similarities
As always, there’s something that puts apart these highly recommended scar treatment medications.
BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is a premium silicone gel-based scar treatment product that’s marketed as the only FDA-Cleared Silishield patented crosslinking medical grade silicone.
It’s not an exaggeration in the actual sense. This product has a commendable reputation among users and is also known to protect scars from the darkening effects of the sun due to scar exposure.
Finally, BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is meant to be applied twice a day for at least 2 months.
On the other hand, Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is an onion extract scar treatment medication that has been around for years and is loved by many users and equally recommended by both surgeons and dermatologists.
It has Cepalin as the main ingredient, alongside other reputable combinations including Allantoin, Panthenol, and Sodium Hyaluronate.
Unlike the BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment, the Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is applied only once per day during the night so that it can complement the skin’s night regenerative activity.
In terms of similarities between these two key scar treatment medications, both are recommended in equal measure by both dermatologists and surgeons.
They both work perfectly fine in reducing scar height and size, softening existing scars and preventing the formation of new scars or keloids.
In a more in-depth comparison of the differences, we will focus on the ingredients, purpose, etc as shown below.
Ingredients
As already mentioned, the BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is a reputable, premium silicon gel-based scar treatment medication that also packs in it the SPF 30 sunscreen known to limit and prevent the formation of new hypertrophic scars.
The Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream, on the other hand, packs together four ingredients with Cepalin as the main ingredient and Allantoin, Panthenol, and Sodium Hyaluronate forming the rest of the ingredients.
In brief, Mederma is an onion extract gel-based scar treatment while BioCorneum is a premium, Silicone-based scar medication.
Price
As one of the major considerations that most users base their buying decisions on, price another differentiator between BioCorneum and Mederma.
As expected, the BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is fairly expensive compared to Mederma’s Scar Cream.
Purpose
Both scar creams are intended for the management and treatment of scars and keloids.
Whether it’s preventing new scar formation, reducing the height and size of a scar or just managing skin discoloration and hyperpigmentation, these two drugs are designed to achieve one goal which is to treat scars.
Effectiveness
As far as the effectiveness of these two medications is concerned, the only differentiation comes in the formulation, taking into consideration the ingredients.
Mederma Overnight Scar Cream is normally inferior in effectiveness when compared to Silicone gel-based formulations like BioCorneum Advanced Scar Treatment.
Nonetheless, Mederma’s products have a good reputation in dealing with scars and keloids. In fact, their more specialized formulations like the Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy is known to be more effective in handling stretch marks than many silicone gel-based extracts.
Mederma’s products also win a good share of user reviews when it comes to dealing with new scars.
Manufacturer
The BioCorneum is designed and manufactured by Sientra, whose headquarters is based in Santa Barbara, California, United States.
The Mederma is manufactured by Merz, with origins in Germany.
BioCorneum or Mederma: Which One is Better for Stretch Marks?
When comparing BioCorneum and Mederma, it’s pretty easy a call to make in deciding which one wins. Mederma’s special formulation, the Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy will always carry the day against BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment.
Mederma is even clinically shown to produce a noticeable improvement in four weeks.
BioCorneum and Mederma: Which One is Best for scars?
For scar treatment and management, BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment carries the day.
This product derives much of its success from the fact that it’s a silicone gel-based extract and also due to the inclusion of SPF 30 sunscreen to help with managing cars.
However, if you’re on a tight budget, you might want to go for Mederma. It’s cheaper and does a good job with scars too.
Which One is Better for new scars?
Although many will front the BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment because of its unique formation for new scars, Mederma’s highly rated Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is equally a good option.
Especially considering the fact that it’s much cheaper to acquire than its competitor under consideration.
Which One is Better for old scars?
Old and stubborn scars call for the use of BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment and not Mederma’s Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream when compared against the other.
BioCorneum Review
BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is simply the perfect medication for scars, bearing a unique formulation of a silicone gel extract and an additional SPF 30 sunscreen to help reduce and limit the formation of new hypertrophic scars.
Pros
- Dries quickly, in less than 5 minutes
- Is odorless and bears a smooth texture
- Bears the Silishield™ technology mark
- Contains SPF 30 sunscreen
- Simple to use medication that requires only two applications per day
- Marketed as the only FDA-Cleared Silishield patented crosslinking medical grade silicone
Cons
- Considerably expensive
- Results require time (patience is key, just like with other scar treatment medications)
Mederma Review
It’s been a darling to many and often recommended especially for new scars by dermatologists and surgeons from around the globe.
You really don’t have to struggle in making a decision to choose this product if you consider the reviews and recommendations it has gained over the years.
The formulation includes Cepalin, a known onion extract that has been in use for years and a combination of Allantoin, Panthenol, and Sodium Hyaluronate making it very effective for its purpose.
Pros
- Just like most Mederma products, it has no undesirable scent and dries really quickly
- It’s really simple to use as it only requires one application per day (at night)
- Takes advantage of the skin’s night regenerative activity to enhance its effectiveness
Cons
- Results take time to realize
Conclusion
BioCorneum Vs Mederma: And the winner is…
So long as you are thinking about treating and managing scars and you have these two options to choose from, BioCorneum Plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Treatment is the winner. Not only because of the silicone gel extract it contains but also because of the additional SPF 30 sunscreen component that it packs together.
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is a good option too and you might even prefer it if you’re on a tight budget.
And if you’re purely considering stretch mark treatment, then you should go for Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy.