best formula breastfed babies

Best‌ ‌Tasting‌ ‌Formula‌ ‌for‌ ‌Breastfed‌ ‌Babies‌ ‌2024‌ ‌(Like‌ ‌Breast‌ ‌Milk)

Most moms want to know which formula milk tastes closest to breast milk before they can settle on their pick from the best tasting formula for breastfed babies. Formulas come in different types which include milk-based, soy protein-based, hypoallergenic and generic formulas.

But then, the formula closest to breast milk would mean the one that features the same compounds in breastmilk. If you’re still breastfeeding, check out the best quiet breast pumps in 2024.

Here’s our list of the top formulas like breast milk.

Winner Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula
  • Has DHA, Lutein, and Vitamin E
  • Has reduced fussiness and gassiness levels
  • Contains no artificial growth hormones
  • Supports brain and eye development
  • Non-GMO
Check Price
Runner-Up & Cheapest Earth's Best Organic Dairy Infant Powder Formula
  • Best for colicky babies and those with acid reflux
  • Non-GMO
  • Easy to digest
  • Does not contain any harsh ingredients that may be difficult to digest for the baby
  • Has organic lactose as the only sweetener
Check Price
Third Best Enfamil Enspire Baby Formula Milk Powder
  • Has Lactoferrin and MFGM to support critical growth
  • Non-GMO
  • Has only lactose as the sweetener
  • Has a proprietary blend of probiotics for the best health
  • Easily digested
Check Price
Top Soy-Based Baby's Only Dairy Toddler Formula
  • Certified USDA Organic with no hormones, pesticides or source of antibiotic-treated cow milk
  • Easy to digest
  • Contains dairy, coconut, and soy
  • BPA-Free Packaging and OU Kosher Certified
  • No Palm Oil, Hexane Processed DHA or Corn/Glucose Syrup
Check Price
Go & Grow By Similac Sensitive Milk Based Toddler Drink
  • Easy to digest
  • A single serving has over 25 essential minerals for growth
  • OptiGRO for best health and child’s development of critical faculties such as the brain
  • NON-GMO based ingredients
  • Suitable for sensitive babies
Check Price

Formulas Like Breast Milk 2024: Reviews

Now, the best baby formula should be gauged on taste, types of ingredients, reaction with the baby, etc. Here are our top 5 of the best tasting formula for breastfed babies 2024.

#1 Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula


The Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant formula is a formula similar to breastmilk in many ways and is recommended for babies between 0-12 months.

It’s best known as among the formulas with the 2′-FL HMO, best known for boosting your child’s immunity.

This Similac formula does not contain any artificial growth hormones and has the lowest fussiness, gassiness and spit-up levels. 

The Similac formula also combines the power of DHA, Lutein, and Vitamin E to help with your child’s overall growth, brain, and eye development. 


  • Has DHA, Lutein, and Vitamin E for better overall growth, brain, and eye development 
  • No artificial growth hormones included thus safe and as healthy as breastmilk
  • Has the 2′-FL HMO for improved immunity of your child in this critical growth stage
  • Combines natural ingredients that help reduce fussiness and gassiness in babies


  • Slightly pricey for some moms

Check Current Price

#2 Earth’s Best Organic Dairy Infant Powder Formula

Runner-up and Cheapest Option

If you are wondering about which baby formula is closest to breastmilk, then you’ve got to consider the Earth’s Best organic dairy infant powder formula.

This baby formula contains both Omega-3 DHA and Omega-6 ARA as well as lutein, iron and prebiotics which are best for boosting your baby’s immunity.

Lutein is good for the development of good eyesight while iron is for blood production. 

It’s one of the easiest to digest baby formulas recommended for the first 12 months and is USDA certified as being an organic-based formula.

This product is probably the best formula for breastfed babies and is recommended as the best option for babies with acid reflux and often are colicky.


  • This product is Non-GMO
  • Best for colicky babies and those with acid reflux
  • Is Kosher certified and does not contain or made with pesticides and synthetic fertilizers.
  • Uses organic lactose as the only sweetener


  • This product is relatively expensive compared to some in its category
  • Babies sensitive to lactose may not benefit from it

Check Current Price

#3 Enfamil Enspire Baby Formula Milk Powder

Third formula closest to breastmilk

If you are keen on only getting the best formula closest to breastmilk, then the Enfamil Espire Baby Formula Milk Powder must be on top of your list.

The brand rallies support behind it as their best formula closest to breastmilk and contains nucleotides, pre/probiotics, fundamental vitamins and other minerals regulated by the FDA.

The manufacturer says it’s the first and only baby formula closest to breastmilk with ingredients as Lactoferrin and MFGM. It has additional choline and DHA for improved brain nourishment.

The Enfamil Espire baby formula has a thick, creamy texture and is not too sweet.


  • Contains a proprietary blend of baby probiotics for best digestive health as well as better immunity
  • It’s a non-GMO formula
  • Only product with Lactoferrin and MFGM
  • Has only lactose as the only sweetener 


  • Not suitable for babies with lactose intolerance

Check Current Price

#4 Baby’s Only Dairy Toddler Formula

Soy-based formula that tastes closest to breastmilk

Here is a formula like breastmilk which is 100% organic available on the shelves today.

As a top-quality formula most similar to breast milk, it contains a perfect balance of DHA and ARA essential fatty acids to facilitates the baby’s overall growth and health levels.

Unknown to many, this organic formula contains no corn syrup, rBST or any GMO-based ingredients. The milk used in the formulation of this organic formula is derived from cows with no trace of steroids, artificial growth hormones or antibiotics.

With a calcium-phosphorus ratio of 1:5, babies using this formula get the best combination of minerals providing optimal conditions for adequate bone development.


  • 100% organic formula
  • Contains DHA and ARA essential fatty acids for eye and brain development
  • Does not contain any palm oil or compromising ingredients
  • Has a calcium-phosphorus ratio of 1:5 ensuring optimal conditions for bone development


  • May not be suitable for sensitive tummies

Check Current Price

#5 Go & Grow By Similac Sensitive Milk Based Toddler Drink

Here is another top of the range formula most like breast milk from top brand Similac.

This Go & Grow formula has the much loved optiGRO formulation that features a blend DHA, lutein and vitamin E just as they are found in breastmilk.

This formulation is Non-GMO and features only natural ingredients with no artificial growth hormones, fertilizers or pesticides.

The formula is easy to digest and helps you balance your baby’s diet as you try out new or different foods.

With just one serving, your baby benefits from over 25 essential minerals and at least 30% daily recommended value of Vitamins C/E, calcium and iron. It also has 96% less lactose and is best for kids with lactose sensitivity.


  • Easy to digest
  • A single serving has over 25 essential minerals and 30% or more of calcium, vitamins C/E and iron recommended values per day
  • Non-GMO ingredients used
  • Perfect for lactose sensitive babies
  • OptiGRO for better health and development of different baby faculties


  • Not recommended for babies with galactosemia

Check Current Price

organic formula supplement breastfed

Which best tasting formula for breastfed babies 2024 wins the competition?

Choosing which formula wins from this list is a rather hard one because all of them are good. However, mothers will first consider the baby’s reaction to the compounds making most formulas and decide whether to go for sensitive formulas or general.

That said, we strongly believe that the Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula wins, followed by Earth’s Best Organic Dairy Infant Powder Formula which is also recommended for babies who are colicky and has acid reflux.

The cheapest of them all would be the Earth’s Best Organic Dairy Infant Powder Formula. All the above formulas are organic and suitable for children within the 0-12 months old bracket.

Is it OK to introduce formula to a breastfed baby?

Yes, and there could be so many situations that would also necessitate a baby to be fed on formula. For example, if the baby has problems with latching, a formula would supplement the little they get.

If the mom is unable to produce enough milk, or the mum is incapacitated from breastfeeding by either sickness or a busy work (travel-ridden) schedule, then the formula would be the only option.

Formulas are formulated using certified compounds that are also found in breastmilk. All you must do is be careful not to choose from a wrong brand or one that would trigger a reaction with your baby.

All said and done, it’s imperative to understand that breastmilk is forever the best food for your baby until they are past breastfeeding age.

breast milk good baby

Should I buy powdered or prepared formula for my baby?

Powdered formula means the formula is in solid form (powder) and you must mix it with water according to standards set by the manufacturer. Prepared formula means it’s ready to be fed to the baby without you adding anything to it.

The choice depends on how much time you have and if you can strictly stay within the proportions set for mixing the formula with water.  Either option is good.

What not to do while introducing formula to a breastfed baby

Here’s the catch though. You must NEVER mix breastmilk and formula and try to feed your baby. You also must NEVER warm your baby’s formula in a microwave.

formula closest breast milk


So there you have it – these are the best tasting formulas for breastfed babies in 2024.

Earth’s Best Organic Dairy Infant Powder Formula, Baby’s Only Dairy Toddler Formula or the much preferred Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula are the formulas closest to breastmilk.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.